The Yale Law Journal

Forum

VOLUME
129
07 Aug 2019

The Predominance Test: A Judicially Manageable Compactness Standard for Redistricting

Michael McDonald

Most states require compact legislative districts, but courts have no framework to judge when contorted districts are legally suspect. This Essay proposes a “Predominance Test” that limits the most egregious gerrymanders by comparing challenged maps to maximally compact plans to test whether compactness predominates over lower-tier and discretionary criteria.

30 Jul 2019

While They Waited: Pre-Obergefell Lives and the Law of Nonmarriage

Michael J. Higdon

This Essay looks at married same-sex couples who, pre-Obergefell, spent time in nonmarital relationships while awaiting the right to wed. In discussing how courts now count those pre-equality years toward the length of couples’ relationships—a decision relevant to adjudicating many benefits—the Essay illuminates weaknesses in current nonmarriage law.

VOLUME
128
VOLUME
127
VOLUME
126
VOLUME
125
VOLUME
124
VOLUME
123
VOLUME
122
VOLUME
121
VOLUME
120
VOLUME
119
VOLUME
118
VOLUME
117
VOLUME
116
VOLUME
115