The Essential Role of Organizational Law
110 Yale L.J. 387 (2000)
In every developed market economy, the law provides for a set of standard-form legal entities. In the United States, these entities include, among others, the business corporation, the cooperative corporation, the nonprofit corporation, the municipal corporation, the limited liability company, the general partnership, the limited partnership, the private trust, the charitable trust, and marriage. To an important degree, these legal entities are simply standard-form contracts that provide convenient default terms for contractual relationships among the owners, managers, and creditors who participate in an enterprise. In this Article, we ask whether organizational law serves, in addition, some more essential role.
The answer we offer is that organizational law goes beyond contract law in one critical aspect, permitting the creation of patterns of creditors' rights that otherwise could not practicably be established. In part, these patterns involve limits on the extent to which creditors of an organization can have recourse to the personal assets of the organization's owners or other beneficiaries--a function we term "defensive asset partitioning." But this aspect of organizational law, which includes the limited liability that is a familiar characteristic of most corporate entities, is of distinctly secondary importance. The truly essential function of organizational law is, rather, "affirmative asset partitioning." In effect, this is the reverse of limited liability: It involves shielding the assets of the entity from the creditors of the entity's owners or managers. Affirmative asset partitioning offers efficiencies in bonding and monitoring that are of signal importance in constructing the large-scale organizations that characterize modern economies. Surprisingly, this crucial function of organizational law--which is essentially a property-law-type function--has largely escaped notice, much less analysis, in both the legal and the economics literature.