The Yale Law Journal

Steven M. Shepard


The Case Against Automatic Reversal of Structural Errors

Steven M. Shepard

117 Yale L.J. 1180 (2008).

This Note describes the case law governing three structural errors and shows that the rule of automatic reversal has led appellate courts to narrow the scope of the rights at issue. To avoid this effect, the Note proposes a new framework for determining whether a given ty…